Hope Is Not a Strategy...But Neither Is Fear

The Good, The Bad, and Our Strategy


  • Falling stocks, stubborn inflation, and worsening geo-politics have made investors fearful.
  • Long-term positives like more attractive valuations and persistent earnings offset the short-term negatives, in our view.
  • We are avoiding undue risk, holding extra cash and focusing on security selection.

The Bad

Stocks are testing investors’ patience: The S&P 500 violated its initial support level of 4200 and is approaching the next level of support at 4000 (for more on technical levels see last week’s Weekly View). If the index definitively breaks below that level, we anticipate additional market downside over the coming weeks.

Inflation has not slowed, and the Fed is now very hawkish: Unfortunately, recent data points suggest that high levels of inflation will be present in the economy for longer than many expected. Ultimately, this means that the Fed can no longer wait and needs to catch up. Rapid rate hikes and other significant tightening measures raise the chance of a policy misstep that forces a hard landing for the US economy (recession).

External factors are getting worse: Geo-politics and other macro-economic factors are worsening as well. Russia's aggression in the Ukraine has not abated, as evidenced by their decision last week to cut natural gas exports to Poland and Bulgaria. Worries are also building that the invasion could extend into regions of Moldova. Additionally, China's COVID-19 lockdowns have grown, placing further pressures on the global supply chain.

The Good:

Valuations are more reasonable: The S&P 500 is down roughly 13% through April 29th. We believe that stocks have fallen to levels where valuations should provide support and a possible entry level for new cash. Given that high valuations were one of our primary concerns entering 2022, the sell-off is a welcome respite from the frothy conditions of four months ago, in our view. Currently, the S&P 500 is trading at a price-to-earnings (P/E) multiple of 17.5x and the NASDAQ-100 is at 22x. These are 2 and 6 multiple points below their January highs, respectively.

Earnings slowing but still positive: Cheap valuations only matter if earnings do not collapse. Thus far, earnings forecasts have stayed robust, and in fact have increased since the beginning of the year. Currently, analysts estimate the S&P 500 12-month forward earnings at over $230 a share, a meaningful increase over the last year (see chart, below).

S&P 12-Mo Forward Earnings-Per-Share Estimate

Source: Refinitiv Datastream, RiverFront. Data weekly as of 4/29/22. Chart shown for illustrative purposes only. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.

US consumer is healthy: The unemployment rate is low, wages are up, and the labor participation rate is rising as Americans return to work. Combine that with the fact that many took the opportunity to pay down debt during the shutdown and one can draw an encouraging outlook for US consumption. Going forward, spending in the US will likely be led by maturing Millennials, who are hitting their prime spending years as they pass through life’s important milestones. Each of these milestones, like getting married, purchasing a home and having children, have historically been economic accelerators and provided a tailwind to GDP.

Bonds more compelling to us with rise in rates: We believe that fixed income investors have been taking short-term pain to start the year, for long-term gain in the coming years. With yields rising quickly, we believe that the time has come to consider adding fixed income to our asset allocation model portfolios. The 120 bp (bp = 1/100th of 1%) increase in 10-year interest rates this year have made bonds more competitive with other asset classes and will serve to re-instill some of the protective qualities of bonds in balanced portfolios, in our view. (For more on our long-term capital market assumptions, check out our recently published Strategic View)

Slowing growth may help the supply chain catch-up: Normally, slowing growth is a bad thing. However, an economy that is growing too quickly places undue pressures on the supply chain leading to inflation and restrictive monetary policy. Thus, some slowing of the economy should be welcomed at times like this. Last week, the Advanced Q1 GDP report was significantly softer than expected registering -1.4% vs an expectation of +1.1%. While one weak data point is unlikely to change the Fed's singular focus on inflation, a corresponding rise in unemployment will put the 'dual' in the Fed’s 'dual mandate' back into play.

Our Strategy:

Expect the unexpected: A key theme in our 2022 Outlook was rising volatility. The best way to endure volatility is to dull your senses to it. Watching the market and one’s portfolio less frequently is one tactic; recognizing that forecasts need to be flexible is another. These are the times when we believe ‘playing the cards you are dealt’ trumps even the best crystal balls. Russia’s attack on Ukraine is a good example of this. While we did not predict it, we had to react and lower our allocation to stocks across our balanced portfolios. Our mantra of ‘Process over Prediction’ relieves the pressure on trying to predict the unpredictable and instead appropriately shifts our focus to what we can control… which is our reaction.

Avoid swinging for the fence: When the unexpected should be expected, we believe it is not the time to ‘swing for the fences’ with one’s investments. In line with this view, over the last year, we have lowered our overall equity weighting as well as the underlying risk of the securities we hold in our balanced portfolios.

A little cash can provide a lot of peace of mind: Each of our balanced portfolios carry more cash than normal; this is especially apparent in the more risk averse, shorter-horizon portfolios. In addition to higher cash levels, these portfolios are also overweight short-term fixed income vehicles like bank loans and/or short-term high yield bonds. The extra cash dampens market volatility and can be used opportunistically to take advantage of pullbacks in stocks or bonds that we would like to add to the portfolio.

Ebbing tide makes security selection paramount: The tide rises when more money is flowing into the markets than coming out of it. Since the financial crisis, low interest rates, monetary stimulus (‘money printing’) and fiscal stimulus created a quickly rising tide. When the tide is rising, all boats are lifted and broad indices like the S&P 500 or NASDAQ often perform best. Going forward the tide appears to be ebbing as rates rise, fiscal and monetary stimulus is withdrawn, and quantitative tightening (QT) begins. In this environment, we think security selection can be expected to perform better than broad index strategies. Over the past 24 months our Advantage portfolios have adapted their selection strategy to reflect this belief by increasing exposure to more granular ETFs and individual stocks while reducing exposure to broad passive indexes.