High Dividend Yielding Stocks Will Continue to Struggle, In Our View

Question: What do you call a stock that pays a consistent dividend that does not grow?

Answer: A ‘bond’!

After 20 years of running global balanced portfolios, we have learned a few things. There are no magic bullets, no crystal balls, and no error-free black boxes. That is because the markets reflect human behavior, and as any sociologist would tell you…humans can be fickle and pretty darn unpredictable. For this reason, the legends of Wall Street and their investment strategies get regularly humbled.

This year it is the dividend stocks – and in particular those that pay the highest dividends- that appear to be taking their turn in the doghouse. One must look no further than five of the most popular dividend indexes (table below) to see their struggle.

Source: Bloomberg, RiverFront. Data daily as of September 15, 2023. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Chart shown for illustrative purposes. An investment cannot be made directly in an index.

In 2022, the defensive nature of the higher yielding sectors led to outperformance but, as the table shows, with the S&P 500 up over 17% YTD, their relative underperformance (3rd Column) has been significant. In this piece we will argue that the underperformance is set to continue and that our expectation for interest rates to remain higher for longer suggests further underperformance.

Rising interest rates are a headwind for dividend stocks: All investment disciplines have an ‘Achilles heel’, including dividend strategies. The Achilles heel of dividend strategies is rising interest rates, and they are negatively affected in at least 3 ways, as outlined below.

1. Rising Interest Expenses: Many dividend companies are highly indebted. For this reason, rising interest rates can have significant negative impacts on a company’s health. As interest payments rise, dividend coverage rates fall, and the risk of future dividend cuts can increase. In our view, the trading range for interest rates will likely remain higher for longer, which is why we expect high dividend yielders to continue underperform from here.

2. Substitution Effect: Rates on the 10-Yr Treasury have risen from 1.5% at the beginning of 2022 to over 4.3% today. As the chart below shows the 2.80% (280bps) jump in the 10-year Treasury yields (blue line) was one of the larger increases in history, nearly tripling the low-water mark for rates in this cycle. As a result, bond yields are now at a 13-year high relative to stock yields (orange line bottom panel). With the rise in rates, investors now have multiple income producing options with competitive yields to choose from, including Treasuries.

Source: LSEG Datastream, RiverFront. Data as of September 14, 2023. Chart shown for illustrative purposes. An investment cannot be made directly in an index.

3. Low Earnings Growth: One of the best ways to fight rising inflation and interest rates is to grow cash flows faster than inflation. Companies that can quickly grow earnings and cashflow have the ability to ‘outrun’ a higher rate environment, because they tend to have a greater ability to ‘pass along’ higher costs to their end customers. Unfortunately, some of the highest-yielding dividend indexes have significantly less exposure to growth-oriented companies and industries and are thus more likely to experience declining profit margins.

In addition to the direct pressures from rising rates, it is also important to note that dividend investing has been one of the hottest trends in investing over the past few years. While there have been many good reasons for its popularity, we think the ‘crowd’ may have gotten to an ‘extreme’ by the end of 2022, because dividend stocks held up relatively well in a tough equity market environment.

The Way Forward: There are ways to make dividend investing less sensitive to rising rates. While you can’t eliminate interest risk entirely, there are ways to lower a portfolios’ sensitivity. Below are a few of our favorites.

  1. Focus on dividend growth: The more a stock looks like a bond, the greater its vulnerability to the direct effects of rising rates. Stocks with the highest dividend yields tend to look the most like bonds, because they have little room to grow their yields. We prefer companies with significant annual dividend growth (greater than 5%). For instance, we find a meaningful number of strong dividend growers in the mega-cap tech space, a theme that we expounded on in our Weekly View in June. These stocks can compete more effectively against bonds in the environment we foresee, since most bonds don’t grow their coupons.
  2. Be more inclusive: When thinking about dividends, we regularly consider new dividend initiators and even a few companies that have yet to pay a dividend but generate significant free cashflow. Often the future’s fastest dividend growers are found in these categories of stocks.
  3. Consider ‘sector neutrality’: Traditional dividend strategies tend to focus on maximizing yields. As a result, they can create significant sector concentrations, like favoring utilities. They can also create absences, like avoiding information technology. Those biases can lead to an underweight in powerfully positive fundamental themes. In our portfolios, RiverFront prefers to focus more on dividend and cash flow growth over simply high dividend payouts.

Conclusion: We Expect the Impact of Higher Rates to Lead to Further Underperformance

The idea that dividend stocks should ‘catch back up’ to a stock market that is up significantly this year, is misplaced in our view. For this to happen, we believe that interest rates would need to decline by a significant magnitude. With the Fed willing to let rates remain ‘higher for longer’ and a strengthening US economy that will likely hold them to their word, we have little faith that rates will be declining to pre-2022 levels anytime soon, if ever.

We think this will be increasingly reflected in the earnings of high dividend payers since some impacts from rising rates will likely be delayed and not reflected in earnings immediately. For example, a company’s interest expense will not change until their lower interest-bearing debt matures and gets refinanced at higher rates. Slower growing companies may also have greater difficulty passing along rising inflation costs to their customers, and the resulting drop in profit margins may only appear later.

As a result, RiverFront portfolios have a greater focus on more high growth sectors like Technology, economically sensitive sectors like Energy and Industrials and an underweight to high-yield, low-growth sectors like Utilities and select areas of Consumer Staples.

Risk Discussion: All investments in securities, including the strategies discussed above, include a risk of loss of principal (invested amount) and any profits that have not been realized. Markets fluctuate substantially over time, and have experienced increased volatility in recent years due to global and domestic economic events. Performance of any investment is not guaranteed. In a rising interest rate environment, the value of fixed-income securities generally declines. Diversification does not guarantee a profit or protect against a loss. Investments in international and emerging markets securities include exposure to risks such as currency fluctuations, foreign taxes and regulations, and the potential for illiquid markets and political instability. Please see the end of this publication for more disclosures.