- We believe the US dollar will maintain its reserve currency status.
- The depth and size of the US bond market is unrivaled, in our view.
- The US is still the dominant economic force in the world, in our view.
“In the land of the blind, the one-eyed man is king.” - Erasmus, 1500 A.D
Since World War II, the US Dollar (USD) has served as the world’s preeminent ‘reserve currency’ – the means of exchange for most of the rest of the world to do business. From central bank holdings to international commerce and commodity transactions, the USD has served as the primary currency, commanding nearly 90% of the world’s foreign currency exchange (FX) transactions (see chart, below).
For years we have fielded questions about how long the USD could maintain its reserve currency status, as threats emerged from both within (related to instability and high debt levels of the US economy) as well as abroad, particularly from the Chinese yuan. These questions have intensified with the latest news that China has been inking deals to use the yuan for cross-border transactions with countries like Brazil, Saudi Arabia, and Iran, as well as with controversy over the US-led sanctions on Russia. Additionally, the steady drumbeat regarding digital currencies also has investors concerned that they may be missing a future reserve currency in its infancy. Is the dominance of the USD as the world’s ‘reserve currency’ set to end?
Don’t believe the hype: We believe that the USD will maintain its reserve currency status for the foreseeable future.
Despite its high debt levels and political division, the US’s economic transparency, openness, flexibility, and governance suggest to us that our financial system is likely to remain at the center of global commerce. The US has problems like any economy, but potential contenders have more as we will discuss. As Erasmus famously said, “in the land of the blind, the one-eyed man is king.”
It is Not Only About Who is the Biggest…But Also Who is the Most Trusted
Dollar skeptics point to the fact that China’s GDP is now larger than the US’s, at least in purchasing power parity (PPP). But when it comes to reserve currency status, sheer size is not everything. Bear in mind that the US became the world’s largest economy by GDP in 1916; yet reserve currency status for the USD did not really happen until after WWII.
Economists point to a mosaic of important factors for a currency’s reserve status outside of just size, including depth and openness of a country’s financial markets, ease of currency convertibility, rule of law, clarity around default resolution, the size and depth of government bond markets, and stability of domestic macroeconomic policies.
By this rubric, we think so-called contenders such as the Chinese yuan fails the reserve currency ‘test.’ Consider:
- Currency Management: The yuan is pegged to the USD, floating within a controlled 2% band, and managed by the Chinese Communist Party for domestic purposes.
- Capital Controls: Alongside currency management, China maintains strict capital controls to restrict outflows of capital outside of mainland China. China has reassured the world that it would liberalize its foreign exchange market since joining the World Trade Organization (WTO) in 2001 but has continued to fall short of that goal, in our view.
- Lack of Transparency: China’s economy is opaque to the rest of the world; data quality and timeliness lags far behind the US and western developed countries, in our opinion. There is an entire cottage industry of economic analysts (including us!), who opine on which official China economic data is the least ‘massaged.’
- High Debt Burden: China’s debt has risen significantly over the past 10 years, as the government financed a debt-fueled infrastructure boom that is now starting to fizzle. Including government debt as well as corporate and household debt, total debt-to-GDP statistics for the Chinese economy are currently at almost 280% of GDP (source: Bloomberg, 5/8/2023). It is understood that China’s myriad local governments also likely have other off-balance sheet unregulated debt lurking in its ‘shadow banking’ system.
- Poor Protections for Dispute Resolution: In the 2017-18 World Economic Forum Global Competitiveness index rankings of 137 countries, China scored much more poorly than the US in areas related to investor protection and economic dispute resolution:
- Legal Rights Index: China ranks 85th; US ranks 4th
- Strength of investor protection: China ranks 102nd; US ranks 31st
- Property rights: China ranks 53rd; US ranks 20th
- No Liquid Bond Market for Foreigners: China lacks a robust government bond market that is widely available to international investors.
Despite its Flaws, US Still the Dominant Economic Force in the World, In Our View
We will be the first to admit that the US has allowed its federal debt-to-GDP level to spiral upwards in recent decades, it is close to a post-war high of 120% as of the first quarter this year (source: Datastream). Deepening political dysfunction and embarrassing episodes such the constant self-inflicted debt ceiling ‘crises’ recently resulted in Fitch becoming the second rating agency to remove the US AAA rating. These episodes are also a challenge to the USD's dominant stance with the international foreign exchange market (FX) community.
It is no wonder that global central banks have sought to diversify slightly away from the USD with regard to foreign currency reserves, into large currencies like the Euro and smaller ones such as the Canadian dollar, the Australian dollar, and the Swiss Franc.
However, despite it all the US economy has proven itself to remain the most productive, flexible, and innovative of its kind in the world, in our opinion. As evidence of that, the US has managed to stay out of recession over the last 12 months, despite the US Federal Reserve’s historic monetary tightening regime and a banking mini crisis.
The Euro is arguably the closest thing the world has to a legitimate alternative to the USD; the Euro commands the second-highest share of worldwide transactions after the dollar (though it is a very distant 2nd). However, we would cite the Eurozone’s lack of a common Euro-wide government bond market as one significant drawback for potential reserves status, as compared to the ubiquity and ease of transaction for US Treasury securities. Furthermore, we believe the deep structural economic, demographic, political, and geopolitical issues facing Europe and north Asia make the Euro and Japanese Yen useful alternatives but no real threat to the USD’s dominance.
What about alternatives to fiat currency, such as gold or cryptocurrencies? There is not enough depth or liquidity in the physical gold market to replace the USD as the global reserve store of value, in our view. And in their brief history, cryptocurrencies have been much too prone to high price volatility to be relied upon as a store of value. Most importantly, crypto currently lives well outside the regulatory system, with few governments willing to recognize cryptocurrencies as legal tender, especially with their propensity to be utilized for extralegal ‘black-market’ purposes.
Finally, there is military might. The US is a trading nation and, like Britain before it, controls the major oceans and thus critical trade routes. China would like to dominate the South China Sea but the major economies of the region outside China such as South Korea and Japan support the US Pacific Fleet’s role. Beyond the seas, the US is still the dominant global military force. The G7 countries from Europe plus Japan and Canada all seek the protection of the US in a crisis and their governments have not challenged the dollar’s status.
CONCLUSION: THE US DOLLAR ISN’T GOING ANYWHERE, IN OUR VIEW
If there was ever a time for the dollar to be superseded it would have been in the last few years as COVID-19 spending drove the Federal deficit ever higher. Yet the USD appreciated versus major trading partner currencies from 2020-2023 (see chart) This speaks volumes to us about the lack of feasible contenders to the USD’s reserve currency status. To paraphrase a Mark Twain quote: the reports of the US dollar’s death are greatly exaggerated.