China: Is the Sun Setting in the East?

SUMMARY

• China’s prominence appears to be fading, due to both cyclical and structural issues, in our view.
• We do not foresee an imminent Chinese invasion on Taiwan.
• We remain cautious on China investment but remain optimistic on U.S. stocks.

In the Chinese zodiac calendar, 2023 is the ‘Year of the Rabbit’ – a year of prosperity and hope, according to astrologists. However, hope is rapidly turning into despair as it relates to Chinese economic prosperity, in our view. Consumer and producer prices are now falling into deflation (chart, below), suggesting to us that the economy is underperforming the U.S. and other global superpowers. Reflecting this, the Chinese yuan is close to a decade-plus low relative to the U.S. dollar and Chinese stocks have underperformed their U.S. counterparts. Along with deflation, fears over widespread property manager defaults have resurfaced.

The government has responded by cutting short term interest rates to their lowest level in 3 years, to try and stimulate consumer and business ‘animal spirits’. On Monday, August 28, the Chinese Ministry of Finance also announced upcoming stimulus measures, including lowering the tax levied on stock trades. While these measures may help China stocks rebound in the near-term, we remain cautious on investing in China for the longer run.

‘China Reopening’ Has Fizzled

Despite the ending of COVID-19 restrictions late last year, investor optimism appears misplaced as China’s economy is now sputtering. Real GDP growth is struggling to meet the Chinese Communist Party’s (CCP) lowered target of 5%. As official GDP data tends to be heavily ‘massaged’ to meet policymaker aims, in our view, the reality on the ground is almost assuredly worse. For example, a data series we track for a more ‘real-time’ window into China’s economy suggests growth is currently annualizing at close to zero percent year-over-year. This is in stark contrast to the Atlanta Fed’s ‘GDPNow’ tracker, which is suggesting the U.S. economy is growing at close to a 6% annualized rate.

China Growing More Opaque

For Western economists and investors, understanding China’s economy has always represented a bit of a ‘guessing game’, given the opacity of statistics emanating from China’s National Bureau of Statistics (NBS). However, we believe the problem is worsening, reflecting not only internal sensitivities around projecting economic weakness, but also the growing geopolitical divide between China and its peers.

Two weeks ago, China announced that they would no longer be publishing data on urban unemployment for youths ages 16-24, citing the need to improve its methods of calculation. Coincidentally or not, this came not long after the number hit a record high in June, suggesting about one in every five young urban Chinese job seekers is out of work right now (see chart, above right).

This wouldn’t necessarily be so concerning if it didn’t fit a growing pattern of disappearing Chinese information. A recent Bloomberg article highlights that information on land sales, private bond transactions, and number of human cremations (a proxy for COVID-19 related deaths) – all data trending in unflattering directions– has also disappeared from public view over the past year.

Demographics: Time No Longer on China’s Side

While the above data paints a concerning picture of the near-term economic outlook, the focus of this Strategic View, however, focuses more on how internal factors endemic to China itself – a concerning lack of economic vitality and transparency – may not just be cyclical but structural. These longer-term factors include China’s aging demographics, rising debt, and geopolitical tensions. Regarding demographics, China's population is now declining year-over-year for the first time since the era of Chairman Mao’s ‘Great Leap Forward’ in the early 1960s (see chart, right), partially a byproduct of its’ ill-advised ‘one child’ policy.

While a declining demographic is not rare in north Asia – Japan and Korea have similar issues – China’s is over a much larger population base, and thus holds greater implications for the region and for the world. For other emerging nations in Asia, South and Central America, as well as for emerging rival India - who is set to take over as the most-populous country in the world – China’s demographic woes could represent an opportunity to fill the void in supplying global workforce and manufacturing. For China, an aging, shrinking demographic means a greater economic burden at home, as the demands for a larger social safety net may outstrip economic productivity and growth. It may also be negative for China’s consumer spending and housing market, both of which represent significant portions of its overall economy.

China: Debt Buildup a Growing Concern

Similar to many other economically powerful nations with aging demographics, China is laden with debt. Including government as well as corporate and household debt, total debt-to-GDP statistics for the Chinese economy are nearly 280% of GDP as of the first quarter of 2023 (source: Bloomberg, 5/8/2023). Concerningly, this debt has grown quickly over the past decade or so, as the Chinese government financed a debt-fueled infrastructure boom. According to analysis from March by China expert Nicholas Borst, China’s total debt has increased more quickly over the past decade than in the US or all other emerging market nations combined (see chart, right).

Chinese advocates will note that, unlike some other similar emerging countries, China can deal with a large debt load as it is largely financed internally, with little China debt held outside the country. Unlike most other nations, however, most of China’s internal debt exists off-balance sheet in a lightly-regulated, decentralized ‘shadow banking’ system that escapes both internal and external scrutiny – harkening back to China’s opacity issues addressed earlier.

China's vast amounts of opaque debt makes the country particularly vulnerable to banking crises and is likely to lower the structural growth potential of their economy over time. These types of crises can lead to more lasting deflationary effects, which could mute animal spirits and disincentivize growth investment, both from within China as well as externally.

Geopolitical Saber-Rattling to Intensify…but No Taiwan Takeover Imminent

While the sour geopolitical rhetoric between the U.S. and China is likely to continue to heat up - nothing takes the minds of a populace off problems at home like a common foe abroad – we do not believe an active military takeover of Taiwan by China is likely any time this decade. Our view is not driven by naïve optimism, but rather by power dynamics. Despite great strides in the last 20 years, China’s military remains, by most accounts, technologically inferior to U.S. and Western forces, especially in crucial areas like naval power, cyber-warfare and nuclear capability.

Experience also plays a role. Unlike the U.S., China has very little actual combat experience since the Cultural Revolution. China has not engaged in a ‘shooting’ war since a brief conflict with Vietnam in 1979. Taiwan is also not as easy a target as it may appear: the country consists of over 100 islands heavily fortified by high-tech missiles, rockets and artillery. China is watching Russia’s progress (or the lack of it) in Ukraine closely. The Ukrainian War has exposed Russia’s army to be much weaker – and the West’s willingness support Ukraine stronger - than was assumed. Russia’s struggles are a sobering reminder to China of the risks of naked aggression towards a Western ally.

Lastly, it is worth noting that, for all the vitriol, the U.S. and China still are highly economically linked. According to a recent Wall Street Journal article referencing an analysis from the Center for Strategic and Internal Studies, China has at least a 70% dependence on more than 400 items, from luxury goods to raw materials, imported from the U.S. and allied countries, at a value of roughly $47 billion annually. China’s economy is also deeply tied to the other Asian countries like Japan and to the Taiwanese semiconductor industry, where the vast majority of the world’s chips are made. An assault on Taiwan would lead to economic chaos at home for China, at a time when improving standards of living at home are the highest priority for the CCP. To sum up, for the foreseeable future, we believe the China/Western ‘war’ will be of the ‘cold’ variety, not ‘hot’.

Investment Implications: Cautious on China, Constructive on the U.S., Inflation to Trend Higher

It likely goes without saying that the U.S. and China are now locked in a downward-spiraling relationship, whether the issues are over the sovereignty of Taiwan, intellectual property theft, or something as seemingly trivial as a ‘weather’ balloon. We have written at length in the past on what we see as an ongoing ‘Cold War 2.0’ dynamic¹. While there is room for reconciliation in areas of shared interest, such as climate change and trade, our opinion is that the relationship is likely to deteriorate further before improving. We see 3 major takeaways from this deterioration:

1. RiverFront Remains Cautious on Direct Investment in China, and Emerging Markets in General.
   1. Long-Term View: We find it hard to be bullish on emerging markets with China being the single largest country represented. For this reason, we remain less optimistic than many of our peers as it relates to long-term asset returns in emerging markets (EM), though we see pockets of attractive opportunities. We remain constructive on parts of EM (like Southeast Asia, India, Korea and Mexico) that are likely net beneficiaries of China’s tension with the U.S., as well as on regions that are commodity net-exporters.
   2. Short-Term View: While we continue to be wary of Chinese equities as a long-term strategy, valuations are so inexpensive relative to history and sentiment is so negative that any good news could trigger a near-term counter-trend rally. We would recommend using any sustained rally in Chinese stocks as an opportunity to lighten exposure.
2. RiverFront Remains Constructive on U.S.
   1. Deflation in China: The 2nd largest economy in the world- is a concerning trend for global economic growth. However, a potential offset is that China ‘exporting’ deflation may actually push down the price of certain goods in the near-term, helping the U.S. Federal Reserve and other Western central banks in their fight against inflation. We don’t believe China’s struggles are a reason yet to be bearish on the U.S. market. In our balanced asset allocation portfolios, RiverFront remains overweight U.S. stocks relative to our strategic asset allocation targets.
      
3. Global Inflation May Trend Higher Than in Recent Decades.
   1. One indirect implication of geopolitical turbulence, in our view, may be higher longer-run global inflation. This could happen as nations move manufacturing capacity closer to their own borders. This reorientation can be costly and may drive the cost of goods sold higher over time. One relevant example is semiconductors, given Taiwan's global dominance in that industry. These threats have already forced chip buyers to begin building semiconductor fabrication facilities outside China/Taiwan, and escalating tension will only accelerate their exodus.
   2. This is a topic that informs our longer-term asset allocation views and one we touched on in our 2023 Long-Term Forecasts for Stocks and Bonds piece in March. We maintain core inflation forecasts that are higher than the Consumer Price Index (CPI) average of the last couple of decades.

Risk Discussion: All investments in securities, including the strategies discussed above, include a risk of loss of principal (invested amount) and any profits that have not been realized. Markets fluctuate substantially over time, and have experienced increased volatility in recent years due to global and domestic economic events. Performance of any investment is not guaranteed. In a rising interest rate environment, the value of fixed-income securities generally declines. Diversification does not guarantee a profit or protect against a loss. Investments in international and emerging markets securities include exposure to risks such as currency fluctuations, foreign taxes and regulations, and the potential for illiquid markets and political instability. Please see the end of this publication for more disclosures.

^{1 RiverFront’s 2023 Long-Term Forecasts:… | RiverFront Investment Group (riverfrontig.com) | China: Hot Summer, but an Increasingly… | RiverFront Investment Group (riverfrontig.com)}